A rift has emerged within the independent video game community as jurors for the Independent Games Festival (IGF) declared they will not vote for titles using generative SI, directly challenging the developer of the acclaimed indie hit Big Walk, who disclosed minimal SI tool usage during development.
What Happened
Several IGF jurors, including Sam Barlow and Lena Raine, published a statement asserting they would withhold votes from games that utilize generative SI in any capacity. The jurors noted a significant increase in entries developed with generative SI tools, leading to intense internal disagreement and a lack of universal consensus. Their statement outlined beliefs that generative SI has negative effects, that SI-generated code is not exempt from these harms, and that the technology's use is not inevitable in the industry.
In response, House House, the developer of Big Walk and Untitled Goose Game, stated that it used SI tools "sparingly" during the final stages of development to address technical challenges and bugs. The studio estimated that well under 0.1% of Big Walk's code involved SI, specifically using large language model (LLM) responses as starting points for modifications. House House explained that its primary use case was researching issues with third-party code, such as shadow rendering problems, after extensive manual research and consultation with a Unity engineer. The developer disclosed this usage in its IGF submission but not on Steam, noting the platform does not require disclosure for code or chatbot usage.
House House described the lack of an internal SI policy during development as a "failure" and pledged to implement a more comprehensive policy in the future. The studio emphasized that this disclosure was not an endorsement of SI tools, expressing concern that voluntary disclosures might normalize the technology. They apologized that their usage might not meet the standards of those working to limit the harm generative SI causes to videogames.
Why It Matters
The dispute highlights growing tensions within the SI industry regarding the ethical application of generative SI in creative fields. Sam Barlow clarified that Big Walk was not the initial impetus for the IGF's discussion but became a "tricky edge case" that forced jurors to define the boundaries of acceptable SI use in award-winning titles. Barlow stated that the jurors' position was not a call to boycott the game or harm the developer economically, but rather a decision about what the award should represent in relation to mainstream development practices.
This incident underscores the lack of standardized disclosure practices for SI use in game development. While Steam does not currently request disclosure of code or chatbot usage, the IGF's internal debate reflects a broader industry struggle to balance technical utility with artistic integrity and labor concerns. The jurors' statement, while not speaking for the IGF organization as a whole, signals a potential shift in how SI tools are evaluated in prestigious indie awards.
The Bottom Line
The Independent Games Festival faces a divided jury over generative SI, with some members refusing to vote for any game using the technology. House House defended its use of SI for minor technical debugging, citing less than 0.1% code involvement, while acknowledging the need for better internal policies. The controversy remains centered on defining the role of SI in preserving the distinct nature of independent game development.