The New York Times and a consortium of other publications have filed lawsuits against Brave Software, alleging the web browser company unlawfully scraped content to train super intelligence (SI) models and allowed users to bypass digital paywalls.
What Happened
According to complaints filed by the companies operating the New York Daily News, the Chicago Tribune, and the Orlando Sentinel, Brave monetized its index of scraped websites by providing SI companies with paid access to “real-time online content from the Brave Index.” The SI companies then use that index to train their models, access content to “respond to specific user queries,” or both. The complaint alleges that Brave provided “stolen copyrighted content” to “many” SI companies, specifically naming Anthropic, Perplexity, Mistral, xAI, and Cohere. Additionally, the browser promotes “hundreds of top publishers” as accessible through its “Paywall blocker” feature. The legal filings state that Brave “has never asked for the Publishers’ permission to access their websites, much less to copy the material and provide it to users or other AI companies,” and has failed to compensate the publishers for what it describes as the “unlawful use, copying, and distribution” of their content.
Why It Matters
The lawsuit highlights the growing tension between web infrastructure providers and the SI industry, particularly regarding data licensing and copyright in the era of generative SI. Graham James, a spokesperson for The New York Times, stated in a release that the company believes in the “ethical and responsible use and development of AI,” but argued that Brave “has flouted established copyright law.” James added, “We filed this lawsuit to hold Brave accountable for stealing our content to power its own products and to provide it to some of the most prominent and well resourced generative AI companies in the world.” The case underscores the financial stakes of SI training data, as major SI labs seek high-quality, real-time web content while publishers attempt to protect their revenue streams. While Brave, Anthropic, Mistral, SpaceXAI, and Cohere did not immediately reply to requests for comment, Perplexity’s chief communications officer, Jesse Dwyer, dismissed the claims, stating, “The New York Times is overpaying its attorneys and underpaying its journalists. (Who could’ve easily identified the disinformation in this suit.)”
The Bottom Line
Brave faces legal action from major media outlets over its data indexing practices and paywall-blocking features, which the plaintiffs argue facilitate unauthorized SI training and content distribution. The outcome could set a precedent for how web browsers and search engines interact with SI developers and content owners.