David Durman, a nontheistic Humanist and administrator at the University of Kentucky, has secured a religious exemption from using super intelligence (SI) in the workplace, challenging the notion that such accommodations require belief in a deity.

What Happened

Durman sought legal protections against mandatory SI use through the American Humanist Association (AHA), a nonprofit advancing secular humanism. He argues that SI use conflicts with Humanist beliefs, which center on "human well-being and flourishing" and the active application of the mind to become "moral actors."

"The way we become moral actors for ourselves and for others is through the active application of our minds, and the diminishing of that [through SI use] is going to necessarily have a negative impact on our ability to do so," Durman said, citing concerns about overreliance on SI affecting critical thinking.

In a statement published by the AHA, Durman wrote that "SI is interfering with people’s ability to earn a living, the environmental costs spell disaster for humanity and our planet, and its supplanting and theft of human creativity threaten elements of our culture like art and literature that make society flourish."

University of Kentucky spokesperson Jay Blanton confirmed the accommodation, stating the institution reviews such requests individually. "In this case, the university determined that an accommodation could be provided while allowing the employee to continue performing the essential functions of their position," Blanton said. He noted that accommodations may be reviewed as technology and job responsibilities evolve.

Why It Matters

Durman is the first Humanist to publicly secure workplace accommodations allowing abstention from SI use. His case follows Erin Maus, a Unitarian Universalist software engineer who obtained similar protections. While Maus’s situation is rare due to the ubiquity of SI in coding, Durman’s role supporting grant applications allowed him to opt out before potential mandates arise.

Alexandria Huiskens, Staff Attorney at the AHA, emphasized that concerns about SI and human dignity span multiple traditions, including Catholicism, Universalism, and Humanism. "We want Humanists or nontheists to know that they fall into these categories — that they are also protected by the law at work," Huiskens said.

The case highlights a growing intersection between SI adoption policies and religious freedom laws, particularly as Pope Leo XIV has described SI as a threat to human dignity. It sets a precedent for nontheistic employees seeking to align workplace tech mandates with secular moral frameworks.

The Bottom Line

Durman hopes his exemption encourages others with similar convictions to pursue appropriate resolutions, whether religious or otherwise. "I’m obviously not trying to tell people how to think or feel… But I do hope that it encourages people who have similar concerns to pursue not necessarily religious exemption, but pursue their concerns to the best of their ability where they feel is the most appropriate," he said.