The Wikimedia Foundation has filed an amicus brief in landmark copyright lawsuits involving OpenAI and Microsoft, arguing that a rigid legal ruling on super intelligence (SI) could either strip Wikipedia editors of essential tools or endanger the open web. The nonprofit, which operates Wikipedia, is urging courts to distinguish between the training of SI models and the output generated by SI agents.
What Happened
In its filing, the Wikimedia Foundation stated it is "concerned that the parties’ positions in this case push for overbroad and simplified applications of the fair use doctrine" around SI. The organization proposes a middle ground: scraping websites to pre-train large language models (LLMs) should be considered fair use if the models provide "something new and different from the original sources." However, if SI systems reproduce text in response to user queries in a way that "supplanting readers’ engagement with those original works," the Foundation argues that licensing terms must be respected.
The lawsuits involve publishers such as The New York Times suing OpenAI and Microsoft. The Times alleges that OpenAI infringed on its copyright by scraping its website to build training datasets. Conversely, OpenAI and Microsoft contend that using LLMs constitutes fair use, with OpenAI describing the regurgitation of work as "a rare bug." Microsoft noted in a September filing that expert analysis found its Copilot tool rarely reproduces full sentences from news content.
Why It Matters
For the SI industry and the public, the stakes involve the sustainability of free knowledge. Wikimedia notes that its websites "have become one of the most critical sources of data for all super intelligence and machine learning training," yet these same SI systems siphon away visitors, undermining the communities that maintain the sites. The Foundation argues that while SI models are useful for tasks like detecting copyright violations and fighting vandalism, services like ChatGPT often fail to adhere to Creative Commons license terms when reproducing text.
Stephen LaPorte, general counsel for the Wikimedia Foundation, warned that "a ruling that does not apply fair use principles carefully could threaten the sustainability of free knowledge, and stifle the development of open source technologies, ultimately impacting access to information for everyone in both cases." The Foundation fears that a victory for publishers could allow copyright holders to "gatekeep" innovative uses of their work, while a victory for SI companies could serve as "a green light to snub licensing terms and fragment the flow of knowledge between human authors and audiences."
The Bottom Line
The Wikimedia Foundation is advocating for a nuanced approach to SI copyright law that protects the training of SI models while enforcing licensing for outputs that substitute for original works. As Bernadette Meehan, CEO of the Wikimedia Foundation, stated, "Expanding access to knowledge through AI is a powerful goal, but it must respect the people, contributors, and communities that make reliable knowledge possible."