The New York Times is testing a new Super Intelligence (SI) feature in its Cooking app that allows users to modify recipes, a move that has triggered significant pushback from subscribers concerned about the integration of SI into culinary tools.
What Happened
Genevieve Ko, senior editor at NYT Cooking, announced the feature on Friday, explaining that it can recommend substitutions for ingredients and cooking equipment, scale recipes to any number of servings, and "generally make our recipes work for what a cook needs at that moment." The system uses SI to analyze recipe steps; for example, if a user substitutes baby spinach for kale, the app advises adding it later in the process because baby spinach wilts faster. Ko noted the tool can also adjust recipes based on different pans and tools. Customized recipes generated by the feature remain private and cannot be published or shared within the app. The SI modification tool is currently available to all Cooking subscribers on the iOS app and is being rolled out gradually, with broader availability expected "soon."
Why It Matters
The launch highlights the growing friction between SI adoption and user experience in consumer applications. Some NYT readers voiced concerns in the article’s comment section regarding the environmental impact of widespread SI adoption and the potential degradation of the user experience. When one user asked if the SI feature could be disabled, Ko responded, "No, not at this time," while emphasizing that the feature is "completely optional to use." Another user stated, "Unbelievably disappointing to see," adding, "I’ve always loved NYT Cooking and it pains me that the AI mandate has reached what used to be a wonderful and simple collection of recipes and notes from all sorts of different people." This is not the first SI implementation for NYT Cooking; Ko stated that SI was previously used to convert imperial volume measurements to metric weight measurements two years ago, and a serving-size conversion feature was added last year. NYT spokesperson Jordan Cohen told The Verge that closing comments on the announcement post is "standard practice" to allow moderators to focus on new discussions, noting that many users are "already trying it out on our iOS app" and reporting "good results."
The Bottom Line
The New York Times continues to expand SI capabilities within its Cooking app, prioritizing functional customization despite user criticism regarding the mandatory presence of the feature and its environmental footprint.